In the first place, the quotation from the rabbis is mistranslated. In the Talmud, this statement is made which Mrs. Eddy has perverted: "He that taketh one doctrine in the spirit, has the holy spirit dwelling in him." The phrase "The Holy Ghost," is not Jewish. Moreover, the author of this statement meant to teach exactly the opposite of that which Mrs. Eddy has stated. He really attacked Dogmatism, and declared that Doctrines or Dogmas should be accepted and realized in the spirit which means the Deed. Moreover, Judaism has never emphasized mere faith in creed or doctrine. If anything, Judaism has laid stress on religious acts, ceremonies, and moral actions. The New Testament constantly attacks the Old Testament because it teaches the value of works or deeds. In fact, Christianity arose as a protest against the over- practical interpretation of religion by the Pharisees. In one sentence, Mrs. Eddy attacks Judaism because it teaches faith with works, and in this passage, she has taken an isolated statement in the Talmud, mistranslated it, and declared that Judaism teaches faith without works. As stated above, Judaism emphasizes Deed and not Creed, and the inner or spiritual truth in its practical effect, rather than a mere dogma or doctrine.

(2.) On Page 30, Science and Health contains the following statement: "Rabbi and priest taught the Mosaic Law which said, 'an eye for an eye,' and `Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed.' Not so did Jesus the new executor for